Carnation – is it really worth getting your car serviced there ??

Before I go ahead with a walk through of my experience, I would like you to answer some questions
1. Was the cost of your service at carnation higher than the cost of your normal service at your earlier service center?
2. Were some parts found to be faulty? Are you sure they were faulty?
3. Did you ever get a call asking for a feedback?
4. If you were offered tea/coffee and you said yes – did you actually get your tea/coffee?

Now for my experience.

It was one fine day that I decided that instead of going to my gm service center, I decided to go to carnation. I could say that it was a bad day because I did not know that I would be duped. So on 20th of November, i took my aveo for service at the Noida sector 63 service station of carnation.

Upon entry i saw that there are not so many cars there. Generally on a saturday or sunday, the service centers are heavily loaded. I thought that it might be better, because I would get better attention. I did not realize that this was due to the fact that most of the prople there are either too rich to care or first-timers like me. My car was taken to the workshop and examined.

They opened the bonet and showed me that the car has hit something due to which the fan is rubbing against some “lamda”. I would have to get a body work done. I was like hell. Cant you move the fan or twist the lamda. They told me that that neither can be done without hurthing the car. I was like… ok… You are the one who know more about the car. Upon delivery, i saw that in addition to the body work (pulling the front grill out), they have also moved the fan to the left — what? but they told me that this was not possible. So a simple “moving the fan” cost me 3000/-. I could have definitely avoided the body work.

Another mechanic came hopping around with his “light in mobile” and told me that the drive belt is faulty. It was totally dark and i was unable to see. I thought that he might be having “night eyes” like to owl to be able to see a fault in such a dark place. But then they showed it to me from below and it was really cracked up. I think that was what which gave me the confidence to trust(wrongly) in them.

Another mechanic hopped and told me that the suspention is leaking. The supervisor who was advicing me first told me that the suspention was fine. But then he looked at the mechanic and then back to the suspention and then according to him the suspention was faulty. It was leaking and should be changed. I should have said no. Now the new suspention which they have put in creaks like anything. I am not an expert and i do not know whether they have put in genuine parts or duplicate parts. They charged me around 2000/- for the suspension. I could have saved that.

And eventually the most absurd thing was when the supervisor told me that the disk brake pads were totally rubbed out. I was like – what? How can he see it without touching or opening them? Maybe they have a way which i am not aware of. I was like ok – replace them. They charged me 2000/- something for the brake pads and 500/- something for the labour. Now, by luck i saw them replace the brake pads. First of all they were not even 50% rubbed. And secondly it was a 5 minute job – just removing some screws, changing the brake pads and putting them back. I paid 500/- for this 5 minute labour job. And i am not even sure now whether they are genuine or not.

One another thing that they replaced was a bearing. The supervisor called me and told me that it is faulty and will not last for even 300 kms. I was like – ok change it. When i went to the shop and took the spare – he told me that it is faulty and i could feel the vibrations if i rotate the bearing. I felt nothing. Except for monetary gain, i am not sure why he changed it.

So, i would have gone to my normal gm service center, this service would have costed me 3000 (body work) + 2500 (brake pads) + 2000 (suspention) + 1500 (bearing) = 9000/- less. The service which was 14000/- would then be only 5000/-.

Now the question is why did I not feel that something was wrong – all the while they were duping me. The reason being that i am not a mechanic. I do not know what part will run and what will not run. Hell, i am not even aware of the location of all the parts. So, it is easy to dupe me. The second reason was that I wanted to get my car serviced by carnation – at least once experience what they have to say? In fact I should have drove out when they told me that the drive belt was faulty without even looking at it.

So, when did i realize that i have been duped? 1 week after the service, the car was as rough as it was before the service. That was when my doubt was confirmed that the service was not worth it. I had realized that i have been duped of a few parts. But 1 week after when the car was as rough as before, I took a look at all the parts. And then I realized that I have been duped.

What could i do? I sent a mail to regarding the fact that i was duped. There was one call where the lady called at around 11 am – and started explaining that the parts that they had changed were supposed to be changed. I told her that I was in a meeting and asked her to call back in 1 hour. I did not get back any calls.

When I get my car serviced at GM, I get a call after a week regarding how the car is performing – or if i am facing any issues. But I never got any such calls from carnation. I believe the business model that Mr. Khatter is following is of duping first-timers. They do not expect the people to return. If by mistake anyone does, he is worth duping again.

Here is the mail that I sent to I did not get any response though.


This is the first time i visited Carnation for servicing my car – Aveo 1.6 LT. For the past 4 years, the car was being serviced by the GM authorized service center in sector 8 noida. The average cost of my service for the past 4 years was around 3000/- per service. At carnation the cost of 1 service was 13800(something) It has been 10 days after the service and the car feels very rough. My previous experience is that the car becomes rough after almost 2 months – when i used to get my car serviced at GM.

5 parts were replaced and a body repairing work was done.

1. brake pads
2. shocker
3. spark plugs
4. drive belt
5. some bearing

Out of the 5 parts,
– the brake pads were fine – i have the old ones and they could still run for another 10,000 kms.
– the new shocker creaks a lot – i am not sure if they put orignial or duplicate.
– the bearing – looked fine to me – i am not sure why it was changed.

In addition to this the body repair for 3000/- was done, which was not required.
I was told that body repair was the only solution – i should have referred a local mechanic as well.

The personal experience was good – but i get almost similar personal touch at GM as well.

Would i get my car serviced at carnation again ?

Reason :
I am not a car mechanic. I cannot tell whether a part is defective or not, genuine or duplicate. The service is not good.
Parts are unnecessarily replaced – even when the current parts are in working condition and doing fine. The service is very expensive – and not worth it.

Service location:
Sector 63, Noida.

2 of my friends who have got their car serviced at carnation have similar feedback.

Jayant Kumar

This review is intended to prevent people from getting duped by carnation. People at carnation ask you for tea/coffee. But if you say yes, you would never get your tea/coffee. Have you noticed it?

An intro to Thrift

What is thrift – a software framework for scalable cross language service development. It combines software stack with a code generation engine to build services that work efficiently and seamlessly between C++, Java, Python, Ruby, Erlang, Perl, Smalltalk etc.

Thrift allows you to define data types and service interfaces in a simple definition file. Taking the definition file as input the thrift compiler generates code that can be used to easily build RPC clients and servers that communicate seamlessly across programming languages.

You can find all this stuff at

My intention here is to provide a step by step guide to installing and building simple services in java/php using thrift. Since till date there is no proper tutorial, this should be helpful.

To download thrift, you can either get it from or do

$ svn co thrift
$ cd thrift

Installation steps

$ ./
$ ./configure
$ make
$ make install

thrift depends on c++ boost libraries. To install boost libraries on ubuntu do

$ sudo apt-get install libboost-dev libboost-doc libboost-thread-dev libboost-python-dev


$ sudo apt-get install libboost-*

One problem i ran into while doing “sudo make install” was

Error: JAVA_HOME is not defined correctly.
We cannot execute java

The solution to this is

$ su
$ <enter password>
$ export JAVA_HOME=/path/to/jdk
$ export ANT_HOME=/path/to/ant
$ export PATH=$JAVA_HOME/bin:$ANT_HOME/bin:$PATH
$ make install

It would install the required libraries for all supported languages.

Now lets try writing a very simple service using thrift and use php/java clients to communicate with the service.

First we need to create a thrift definition file.

$ mkdir test # create a separate working directory
$ cd test
$ vim time.thrift # paste the following code in time.thrift

namespace java tserver.gen  // define namespace for java code
namespace php tserver  // define namespace for php code

typedef i64 Timestamp

service TimeServer {  // define the service you want to implement
  Timestamp time(),   // define the funcionalities the service would provide.
            string date(),
            i64 multiply(1:i32 num1, 2:i32 num2),

Namespaces are the places where code would be generated – what we call package in java.

Create a separate directory to store source files

$ mkdir src
$ cd src
$ vim

Create a java source file for implementing the functions that we had defined in the time.thrift file. The name of the file is the Service name (as defined in the thrift file) followed by “Impl”. Provide the body of the functions in this file.

package server;

import java.util.*;
import org.apache.thrift.*;
import tserver.gen.*;

class TimeServerImpl implements TimeServer.Iface
  public long time() throws TException
    long time = System.currentTimeMillis();
    System.out.println("Current time : "+time);
    return time;

  public String date() throws TException
    Calendar now = Calendar.getInstance();
    String dt = now.get(Calendar.YEAR)+"-"+(now.get(Calendar.MONTH)+1)+"-"+now.get(Calendar.DAY_OF_MONTH)+" "+now.get(Calendar.HOUR_OF_DAY)+":"+now.get(Calendar.MINUTE)+":"+now.get(Calendar.SECOND);
    System.out.println(" date : "+dt);
    return dt;

  public long multiply(int num1, int num2) throws TException
    System.out.println("Got : "+num1+", "+num2);
    return num1*num2;

$ vim

Create a file for providing the service. This program simply has a main function which binds the service to a particular port and makes the server ready to accept connections and provide response. This code will generally remain constant unless you want to provide additional functionality at server level.

package server;

import org.apache.thrift.protocol.*;
import org.apache.thrift.protocol.TBinaryProtocol.*;
import org.apache.thrift.server.*;
import org.apache.thrift.transport.*;
import tserver.gen.*;

public class Server
  private void start()
      TServerSocket serverTransport = new TServerSocket(7911);
      TimeServer.Processor processor = new TimeServer.Processor(new TimeServerImpl());
      Factory protFactory = new TBinaryProtocol.Factory(true, true);
      TServer server = new TThreadPoolServer(processor, serverTransport, protFactory);
      System.out.println("Starting server on port 7911 ...");
    }catch(TTransportException e)

  public static void main(String[] args)
    Server srv = new Server();

$ vim

And create a client which will connect to the server on the specified port and call the provided functions.

package client;

import org.apache.thrift.*;
import org.apache.thrift.protocol.*;
import org.apache.thrift.transport.*;

import tserver.gen.TimeServer.Client;

public class TimeClient {
  private void start(){
    TTransport transport;
    try {
      transport = new TSocket("localhost", 7911);
      TProtocol protocol = new TBinaryProtocol(transport);
      // this client depends on the client class in the gen-java/tserver/gen/ file
      // public static class Client implements TServiceClient, Iface
      Client client = new Client(protocol);;
      long time = client.time();
      System.out.println("Time from server:" + time);
      String dt =;
      System.out.println("Got date from server: "+dt);
      long res = client.multiply(30,100);
      System.out.println("Multiply from server: "+res);
    } catch (TTransportException e) {
    } catch (TException e) {

  public static void main(String[] args) {
    TimeClient c = new TimeClient();

Now lets move ahead and generate the thrift code. And compile everything.

$ thrift –gen java time.thrift
$ vim build.xml

Write a simple build.xml to build these files

<project name="tserver" default="tserver" basedir=".">
<description>Time Server Tutorial</description>

<property name="src" location="src" />
<property name="gen" location="gen-java" />
<property name="build" location="build" />
<property name="cpath" location="/usr/local/lib/libthrift.jar:/usr/local/lib/slf4j-api-1.5.11.jar" />

<target name="init">
<tstamp />
<mkdir dir="${build}"/>

<target name="compile" depends="init">
<javac srcdir="${gen}" destdir="${build}" classpath="${cpath}" >  
<compilerarg value="-Xlint:deprecation"/> 
<javac srcdir="${src}" destdir="${build}" classpath="${cpath}:${gen}" >   
<compilerarg value="-Xlint:deprecation"/> 

<target name="tserver" depends="compile">
<jar jarfile="tserver.jar" basedir="${build}"/>

<target name="clean">
<delete dir="${build}" />
<delete file="tserver.jar" />


If you will check out the build file, you will see that the classpath contains slf4j-api-x.y.z.jar file. Download these files from and put two files (slf4j-api-x.y.z.jar and slf4j-simple-x.y.z.jar) from the archive in the /usr/local/lib directory to satisfy the required dependencies.

To complile the file run ant and create two files runClient and runServer to run the server and clients.

$ ant
$ cat runClient
java -cp tserver.jar:/usr/local/lib/libthrift.jar:/usr/local/lib/slf4j-api-1.5.11.jar:/usr/local/lib/slf4j-simple-1.5.11.jar client.TimeClient
$ cat runServer
java -cp tserver.jar:/usr/local/lib/libthrift.jar:/usr/local/lib/slf4j-api-1.5.11.jar:/usr/local/lib/slf4j-simple-1.5.11.jar server.Server

On compiling you will get the tserver.jar file created.

Now run the server and the client

$ ./runServer
Starting server on port 7911 …

$ ./runClient
Time from server:1270726146716
Got date from server: 2010-4-8 16:59:6
Multiply from server: 3000

Now lets try building a client in php. First we will generate the thrift-code for php and then write the client to interact with the java server.

$ thrift –gen php time.thrift
$ mkdir php # create a directory to store your php client source code.
$ cd php
$ vim PhpClient.php


//location of thrift php libraries
$GLOBALS['THRIFT_ROOT'] = './lib';

require_once $GLOBALS['THRIFT_ROOT'].'/Thrift.php';
require_once $GLOBALS['THRIFT_ROOT'].'/protocol/TBinaryProtocol.php';
require_once $GLOBALS['THRIFT_ROOT'].'/transport/TSocket.php';
require_once $GLOBALS['THRIFT_ROOT'].'/transport/THttpClient.php';
require_once $GLOBALS['THRIFT_ROOT'].'/transport/TBufferedTransport.php';

$GEN_DIR = '../gen-php';
require_once $GEN_DIR.'/time/TimeServer.php';
require_once $GEN_DIR.'/time/time_types.php';

try {
  $socket = new TSocket('localhost', 7911);
  $transport = new TBufferedTransport($socket, 1024, 1024);
  $protocol = new TBinaryProtocol($transport);
  // this client depends on the client class in the gen-php/time/TimeServer.php file
  // class TimeServerClient implements TimeServerIf
  $client = new TimeServerClient($protocol);


  $time = $client->time();
  print "time frm server = $timen";
  $res = $client->multiply(100,5000);
  print "multiply frm server = $resn";

} catch (TException $tx) {
  print 'TException: '.$tx->getMessage()."n";

As you can see, in the code, the thrift library for php is included in the lib directory inside the php directory.
Create the lib directory and copy the required library files from thrift installation directory to the lib directory.

$ mkdir lib
$ cp -r /path/to/thrift/lib/php/src/* lib/

Now try running your php client. Remember to fire up your java server.

$ php -q PhpClient.php

You may get tons of errors “failed opening ‘./lib/packages/time/time_types.php’ for inclusion”. For this you will need to edit the generated php files. The time_types.php file is in the generated directory “gen-php”.

$ vim ../gen-php/time/TimeServer.php

Add the following lines

include_once '../gen-php/time/time_types.php';
//include_once $GLOBALS['THRIFT_ROOT'].'/packages/time/time_types.php';

now “php -q PhpClient.php” works…